Defining What We Are Not


Elections, Identity, and Our Intertidal Moment


The term intertidal describes the stretch of shoreline exposed at low tide and submerged at high tide, a dynamic, unstable environment where wave action continually reshapes the terrain, often abruptly and unpredictably. If you’ve ever stood on a beach and felt the sand pulled from beneath your feet as a wave recedes, you already understand the disorientation such conditions can create.

Doesn’t that sound like the environment we are navigating today?

I’m going to dip my digital pen in political ink for a moment. But my point isn’t about politics. It’s about navigating what I call an Intertidal Moment.

Many have described the 2026 midterm results as a blue wave, even a blue tsunami. The metaphor fits. Yet if we zoom out, we see that every election cycle since at least 2016 (some would argue earlier) has been dramatic and unexpected.

Consider the pattern. In 2016, an outsider won the presidency against nearly every prediction. Two years later, a blue wave handed Democrats the House. In 2020, the White House flipped again. The red wave predicted for 2022 barely reached shore: Republicans narrowly took the House, and Democrats held the Senate. In 2024, a Republican sweep was hailed as a lasting realignment. Two years later, it was swept out to sea.

Supporters of each wave were sure it marked the permanent shoreline. It never did. Conviction gave way to disappointment, and disappointment fed the next wave.

Even the forecasters keep getting it wrong. Polls underestimated Trump in 2016, 2020, and 2024. This year, they missed in the opposite direction, underestimating Democrats by roughly four points—a wider miss than in 2016.¹ Pollsters will debate methodology for months. But part of the answer may be simpler: it's hard to forecast what's still in motion.

Losing Our Bearings

These swings may be unexpected, but they shouldn’t surprise us. We are living through an Intertidal Moment—the turbulent space between what was and what is becoming. The change isn’t confined to politics; it’s everywhere, all at once. Familiar structures are being swept away like sandcastles. Old narratives no longer fit the story we’re living. The path ahead feels uncertain, with waves of change building on the horizon.

Perhaps the greatest casualty is one most of us never noticed we had: direction. Until around the turn of the millennium, we didn’t have to find it; we received it. Culture, career tracks, institutions, and expectations defined not only what the good life looked like and how to get there, but what we could expect in return for our effort. They taught us to be something: a title, a role, a rung on the ladder. No more. The milestones that once came with instructions now dissolve, like those sandcastles, into a continuous “now what?”

We aren’t the only ones losing our bearings. The institutions that once provided direction, from schools and employers to the media and houses of worship, are now struggling to find their own. Chief among them are governments and those who hold office, often the last to acknowledge when rising water has swamped the tide pool of authority they once thrived within. Like a child frantically piling sand against the incoming tide, many try to save the castle rather than adapt and risk irrelevance. Others work to shape a narrative that serves their own vision of the future, usually a self-interested one. The result is a collision of competing narratives, leaving a population losing its footing and a future shrouded in fog.

Nowhere is that sand-piling more visible than in political posturing. Over the past decade, accusations of rigged elections, illegal voting, and voter fraud have steadily escalated, each an attempt to control the tide rather than read it. A subtler version surfaced within days of this election. Asked whether the White House should change course, House Speaker Mike Johnson declined, pointing instead to his party’s “incredible record.” Then he added, “I’m sorry that the voters made the wrong choice.”²

In other words, his map of the world wasn’t wrong; the voters were.

The confusion doesn’t end when a new wave breaks. It simply changes direction. Almost immediately, questions have arisen about how those swept into power by the blue wave will lead. It is one thing to ride disappointment and dissatisfaction into office; it is another entirely to chart a course through the perpetual churn an Intertidal Moment delivers.

We’ve been here before.

In the 1890s, as industrialization remade an agrarian nation, control of Congress lurched from one party to the other in wave after wave. In the 1930s, the Great Depression swept away the old order, and voters handed power to leaders willing to chart a new course.³ Each time, the tide eventually settled into a new shoreline, but only after those clinging to the old one were washed out. Even the parties themselves get reshaped. The Republicans who once championed high tariffs and federal power became the party of free trade and limited government, while Democrats traveled the opposite road.⁴ The labels endure. What they stand for does not.

Which is why our current political strife isn’t really about party loyalty or reclaiming what was. Intertidal Moments aren’t about the past; they’re about the future. Yes, change is unsettling, even frightening, and in response some will inevitably insist that yesterday’s ideologies and traditions are the only acceptable vision for what comes next. But the tides of change have never waited for anyone’s permission.

So we drift, pulled by digital currents engineered by a few to shape what we believe and what we want. And we swing, rewarding whoever promises to restore the ground beneath our feet, then punishing them when the sand keeps shifting.

Finding Our Compass

We treat each election as if it might be the final wave, hoping the sand will finally settle. It won’t, because the shifting runs deeper than politics. The truth is, elections aren’t really about politics at all. They’re about us, the kind of world we want to live in, the future we want to build. That is the difficult part: determining what we want, who we want to be, and what we stand for. In essence, it comes down to our values and identity in a world swirling with change. So we experiment. We try on different identities, beliefs, and allegiances. And as we do, we begin to define who we are by deciding what we are not.

Seen through an intertidal lens, the political turmoil begins to make sense. Those who seek to control the levers of government are competing to define an identity the majority will accept as its own. But identity can’t be defined by someone else. It has to be claimed and owned.

Elections can change who holds power, but they can’t set our direction. They can’t hand us a compass. That we have to find for ourselves. Elections are simply how we organize around what we find. Make no mistake: the future will not look like the past. The only question is whether we’ll navigate it by choice or be carried by conformity.

The old world taught us to be something. This one asks us to be someone.


Subscribe


The ideas in Pragdealism are adapted from my book, Seeker's Mindset.

To learn more, visit: www.seekersmindset.com.



Notes:

¹ “Polls Missed Bigger on the Midterms than in 2016,” Axios, November 4, 2026, https://www.axios.com/2026/11/04/polling-midterms-accuracy-atlasintel.

² Ahmad Austin Jr., “Mike Johnson Swipes at the Electorate as He Returns to DC for Swan Song as Speaker: ‘The Voters Made the Wrong Choice,’” Mediaite, November 9, 2026, https://www.mediaite.com/politics/mike-johnson-swipes-at-the-electorate-as-he-returns-to-dc-for-swan-song-as-speaker-the-voters-made-the-wrong-choice/.

³ Jeremy C. Young, “Is America in the Midst of a Political Realignment? (Guest Post),” U.S. Intellectual History Blog, July 2016, https://s-usih.org/2016/07/is-america-in-the-midst-of-a-political-realignment-guest-post/.

⁴ Jeffrey Frankel, “Republicans’ Protectionist Pedigree,” Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, Harvard Kennedy School, June, 13, 2018, https://www.belfercenter.org/publication/republicans-protectionist-pedigree.

Rick Thomas

Author | Speaker | Entrepreneur | Pragdealist

Author Bio

https://www.linkedin.com/in/rickathomas/
Previous
Previous

The Irony of Speed

Next
Next

The Rule of Least Concern